Valentine’s Day is soon upon us, which means we’re all in need of some cheery Netflix rom-coms in which very attractive and well-dressed people have romantic crises in cute apartments, right? I am but here to serve! While there doesn’t appear to be anything brand-new that fits the bill on the streamer, I watched and rated four newish ones (all from 2023). Wishing you all a happy and perfectly accessorized Valentine’s Day!
“Your Place or Mine”
(Netflix original; 111 minutes)
The premise: Harry and Sally, oops I mean Debbie (Reese Witherspoon) and Peter (Ashton Kutcher), have been platonic best friends for 20 years in that grand rom-com tradition — despite being polar opposites who live on opposite coasts. But when single mom Debbie’s babysitter falls through before her planned trip to New York, Peter offers to fly to Los Angeles to stay with the kid. Worlds collide, secrets are revealed and guess how it ends. Really, just guess.
The setting: We alternate between Debbie’s cozy, cluttered California bungalow and Peter’s sleek, practically empty, ultramodern New York apartment where he keeps a Secret Manuscript in his oven, which seems like a dumb place to hide something if you’re having a houseguest.
The chemistry: Witherspoon and Kutcher are pros at this sort of thing, but they’re hampered by a script that has them on opposite coasts for nearly the entire movie. It’s hard to banter in split-screen, and harder still to make this story (in which Peter magically becomes the world’s greatest dad, and Debbie, for some reason, never removes her one pair of sandals, to the point at which I worried they were permanently fused to her feet) believable.