Marley Spoon: Maybe it’s just Martha Stewart’s charisma, but this service delighted me. The app and website are easy to use, transparent about prices (no small feat) and filled to the brim with gorgeous-looking recipes. I was most taken by the variety; these are not just for dinner. Meals can be breakfast (overnight oats), even dessert. Yes, I ordered a birthday cake. The delivery was the most confusing part; all of the produce came together in one little box, like someone had just filled it up at the farmers market. Cute, but it took time to sort things out by recipe. And some vegetables were so overripe they were leaky and a bit smelly. (They credited my account when I lodged a complaint through the app.) marleyspoon.com
HelloFresh: The first subscription I canceled is an otherwise popular one. There were a few too many shortcuts, to the point where I felt like I wasn’t doing any cooking, even when I wanted to. For example, I ordered an empanada meal I thought would appeal to my kids. What I received was a bag of frozen mini empanadas I could have bought at the store, a pouch of pre-sliced apples, and a bladder of yellow cheese sauce that looked like it came out of a pump. The dinner entree, a baked mashed potato casserole, was heavy. And when I ordered a four-serving meal, they sent four plastic packets of every item — four bags of chives, four bags of cheese, etc. Environmentally, it didn’t feel right. hellofresh.com
Green Chef: An all-organic, nutritious and a little more grown-up offering from HelloFresh. Just browsing the app felt like a healthy act. You can choose your meals by diet — low-carb, high-protein, keto, etc. Breakfast egg bites, smoothies and protein shakes were available as add-ons at checkout. The recipes offered more global flavors than its sister company, and while it nudged me in the Mediterranean direction with its suggestions, I enjoyed swapping my selections for 10-minute salads, Moroccan turkey tagine and fish tacos. greenchef.com
Gobble: Chopping vegetables is one of my least favorite activities, so I was drawn to this brand by the promise that their “sous chef” would do the prep work for me. Instead, I got whole veggies that needed to be scrubbed and peeled, while the primary components of the dish — the ones I actually wanted to put my own stamp on — were already cooked. Pot roast arrived as chunks of meat in a plastic bag, reminding me too much of canned stew; mashed potatoes were sent to me cooked and in pouches. On the flip side, the one prechopped vegetable, cauliflower, had turned to mush before I’d had a chance to use it. (They did credit my account after I wrote them an email.) gobble.com