The following is presented as part of The Columbian’s Opinion content, which offers a point of view in order to provoke thought and debate of civic issues. Opinions represent the viewpoint of the author. Unsigned editorials represent the consensus opinion of The Columbian’s editorial board, which operates independently of the news department.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis hasn’t announced that he’s running for president, but he’s doing a convincing job of acting like a candidate.
DeSantis, who rarely speaks without reminding listeners that he won reelection by a margin of almost 20 percent, is on a coast-to-coast tour to court Republican voters and contributors. The goal appears straightforward: Become the consensus alternative to the party’s presumptive front-runner, former President Donald Trump.
He’s already succeeding. Public opinion polls, which at this point are entertaining but not predictive, show DeSantis firmly in second place — in a race he hasn’t entered.
“It’s unusual that you have two people so clearly out front at this early stage,” GOP strategist Alex Conant told me, referring to DeSantis and Trump. “That’s going to make it hard for other potential candidates to make any headway.”
DeSantis has bootstrapped his way to the top of the conservative heap by casting himself as a bare-knuckled brawler in the culture wars.
During the pandemic, he derided Dr. Anthony Fauci and ordered schools to reopen before most other states did. He chartered a jet to dump asylum-seekers on the mostly liberal enclave of Martha’s Vineyard, Mass. He enacted a law to ban teachers from discussing sexual orientation before the fourth grade. When Disney executives criticized the law, he denounced them as “woke” and stripped Disney World of its status as a self-governing district.
Fox News hailed him as a hero. And to many GOP donors and voters, he began to look like a potential fusion candidate — militant enough to appeal to Trump fans, but conventional enough for Republicans tired of the former president’s chaotic style.
Trump noticed with mounting anger. He dubbed DeSantis, whom he once endorsed, as “Ron DeSanctimonious.” DeSantis wisely avoided trading insults with the most accomplished mudslinger in modern politics. “It’s silly season,” he said.
But Trump’s attacks are unlikely to stop there. “The question is: Does any of it stick, and how does DeSantis handle it?” Conant said.
DeSantis has not been nimble on one test: figuring out a coherent position on the war in Ukraine.
As a hawkish congressman in 2014, he criticized then-President Barack Obama for failing to send weapons to Kyiv. “When someone like (Russian President Vladimir) Putin sees Obama being indecisive, I think that whets his appetite to cause more trouble,” he said.
But last month, DeSantis criticized President Joe Biden for sending Ukraine too much aid. If there is a guiding principle, it’s hard to find — unless it was merely opposing a Democratic president.
DeSantis still has a few months to work on his positions. But he’ll face a full-scale test in August, when Republicans have scheduled their first presidential debate.
It’s likely to be a tough one, because every other candidate will be gunning for him — not only Trump, but all the others, since they want to take DeSantis’ place as the leading alternative.
If DeSantis stumbles, several understudies may vie to replace him: former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley, former Vice President Mike Pence, Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina and perhaps others. And non-Trump Republicans will again face the challenge of coalescing around a single alternative, mindful of 2016 when a large, fragmented field helped Trump win the nomination.
It may be a cliche, but it’s true: The stakes in this campaign go beyond choosing a nominee. The race will determine the future of America’s conservative party.
If the GOP is still defined by allegiance to Trump, as it was in 2016 and 2020, then he’ll be its nominee.
If most Republicans want to move beyond Trump to a less chaotic version of conservatism — or merely want a candidate who seems more electable — DeSantis has made himself a logical choice.
