Joe Callerame threw a pair of touchdown passes to Lance Stuck, but Seton Catholic had no answer for Conan Baxter as Elma beat the Cougars 61-26 in a non-league game on Friday.
Baxter had six touchdown runs and returned an interception for another.
After Elma went up 27-0 in the second quarter, Stuck caught an 18-yard touchdown pass from Callerame to get Seton on the board. After Cougars recovered an onside kick, Callerame hit Stuck on a 24-yard touchdown pass to cut the score to 27-14.
But Elma responded with a 24-yard touchdown run by Jerred Bailey to take a 35-14 lead into halftime.
Baxter added three touchdown runs, plus his interception return for a score to put the game out of reach in the third quarter.