In a 2018 resolution, the council expressed an intention to designate council Position 1 as mayor after the restructuring proposition passed. After the proposition passed, the council appointed current Mayor Molly Coston, who was elected in 2017, to a term that expires next year.
Coston voted in favor of the resolution Monday. She said she hasn’t made any decisions about running for re-election.
Coston said in an email that she heard from many voters after the 2018 election who indicated that they only voted in favor of the proposition because of the intention to revert the mayor position back to an elected office.
“In addition, I believe that this is a more democratic and transparent way to operate our local government,” Coston wrote. “The voting citizens of the community elect their mayor. Period.”
Current Position 1 Councilor Brent Boger’s term expires next year as well. Boger voted in favor of the resolution.
“I move that we abolish my council position,” Boger said with a laugh at Monday’s meeting.
Boger said that appointing mayors exacerbates weaknesses in council-manager systems, most viscerally in interaction between the city and residents.
“City manager systems tend to be more bureaucratic and sometimes accountability is not clear to the public,” Boger wrote. “An elected mayor is a valuable conduit between the public and city government.”
Councilors Paul Greenlee and Michelle Wagner voted against the resolution. The councilors didn’t explain their reasoning Monday and did not respond to requests for comment.