The following is presented as part of The Columbian’s Opinion content, which offers a point of view in order to provoke thought and debate of civic issues. Opinions represent the viewpoint of the author. Unsigned editorials represent the consensus opinion of The Columbian’s editorial board, which operates independently of the news department.
President lost on the shutdown, but can still win on border wall
By Marc Thiessen
Published: February 3, 2019, 6:01am
Share:
Having lost the shutdown standoff, President Trump has also lost his leverage. But there is one way he can get it back.
Democrats are standing firm in opposition to a border wall, but they have also been at pains to argue that they are not weak on border security. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and Senate Minority Leader Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., say Democrats support “smart, effective border security solutions — just not the president’s wasteful and ineffective wall.”
Trump should call their bluff.
He should go back to the experts at the Department of Homeland Security and ask them: If Democrats refuse to give you the additional physical barriers you have said are essential to secure the border, what other funding would you need to make up for it? How many extra border agents would you need in the absence of a wall? How many more canine units? How much more for improved coordination with state and local law enforcement in our border communities? How many more Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents for interior enforcement? How much for underground sensors, radar, unmanned drones and fixed towers with infrared cameras? How much more advanced detection technology at our ports of entry? How many more portable scanners to detect smuggled narcotics, weapons and other dangerous materials? How much for construction of new ports of entry? How many more immigration judges? How much more in humanitarian assistance and medical support for those detained at the border? How many more detention beds and temporary housing units for migrant families? How much more for DNA testing to establish family relationships? How much to set up a new system that will allow Central American minors to apply for asylum in their home countries?
The total, he should tell the border professionals, can be far more than $5.7 billion. Just tell me what you need — the sky’s the limit.
Then, the president should use his State of the Union address to demand that congressional Democrats fund every single penny. He should announce that if Democrats won’t pay for a wall, this is what border agents and homeland security professionals say they need immediately to secure the border without one. Unfortunately, it is more expensive to secure the border with people and technology than it is with steel slats.
Trump should make clear these demands are nonnegotiable. He will not make any concessions for them. No protections for “Dreamers” or extension of the Temporary Protected Status program. Those things are still on the table, but only in exchange for a physical barrier.
If Democrats refuse, Trump will have the moral high ground. He can tell the American people: First, the border professionals told us they needed an additional 230 miles of physical barriers, and Democrats refused. Now, they have told us what they need to secure the border without those physical barriers — and Democrats still refuse. The Democrats are not against a wall; they are against border security, period.
But Democrats will not refuse, because they have no grounds to do so. They have repeatedly claimed over the past few weeks to support such measures.
Such a massive border security request would divide the Democratic caucus. While Democratic leaders claim they want to secure the border, their rank-and-file members do not. Those members want to abolish ICE, not give it more resources. If Trump wants to pit the likes of Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., and her followers against Pelosi, this will do it.
If Democrats agree, then Trump canlegitimately claim to have done more than any president to secure the border. He will have essentially built a virtual wall. And he can do all this without giving up on a physical barrier.
Morning Briefing Newsletter
Get a rundown of the latest local and regional news every Mon-Fri morning.
