A simple mac and cheese may be the ultimate comfort food, but sometimes it’s fun to change things up or go beyond the kind that comes in a box, if that’s your reliable standby. Whether you only want to add your favorite cheese or instead feel like adventuring into “you fancy!” territory, mac and cheese can accommodate whatever level of creativity you’re up for. Scour your pantry and fridge, or the local gourmet market, for pastas, cheeses, meats, vegetables and condiments that can easily dress up an already irresistible dish. Start with our Classic Macaroni and Cheese recipe, then play around with these variations or invent your own. Of course, this guide doesn’t include every possible mac-and-cheese ingredient, but it’s a great starting point to help you spread your wings beyond the basics.
Step 1: Pick your pasta: Orecchiette, cavatappi, cavatelli, cellentani, ditalini, farfalle, macaroni, penne, pennette, radiatore, rigatoni, rotini, shells (small and medium).
Use 1 pound of any of these shapes, which excel at holding onto a cheesy sauce. Feel free to mix and match if you have a few ounces of several different shapes leftover; just make sure they cook for about the same amount of time.
Tip: Don’t put oil in the water used for boiling the pasta. The cheese won’t cling to the pasta as nicely.