Overwhelming evidence leads you to conclude that you’re a complete failure. Maybe everything would be better if you’d never even existed.
But then a miracle occurs, and you learn a profound lesson: Because of you, everything is better. You really do have a wonderful life.
That’s not just the biography of humble hero George Bailey and his journey from striving to despair to faith, it’s also the history of this beloved holiday classic. To say that “It’s a Wonderful Life” was not especially beloved when it was released in 1946 is putting it mildly. Critics mostly liked the film while still knocking its sugary sentimentality — but the box office itself leveled the ultimate judgment. Faced by stiff competition like “The Best Years of Our Lives” and “Miracle on 34th Street,” the elaborate and expensive-to-make “It’s a Wonderful Life” lost money in general theatrical release.
Heartwarming holiday tale? Any film that features Jimmy Stewart screaming at his adorable kids and planning suicide has got to qualify as dark, twisted and desperate. The FBI, noting the film’s pointed class consciousness — virtuous poor versus evil banker — even warned that it could be considered Communist propaganda.