Commentary: Please, can’t we just agree to disagree
Sunday, June 15, 2008 By Greg JayneColumbian Staff Writer On the surface, when you consider it was a story about college baseball and a story out of Mississippi, it all seems so minor.
Yet there’s something about Ron Polk’s tirade, something about the venom it portrayed, that somehow speaks to a larger societal issue.
Polk is retiring after nearly three decades as baseball coach at Mississippi State. He’s the winningest coach in Southeastern Conference history, and he six times has led the Bulldogs to the College World Series.
So far, so good.
But as he was walking out the door, Polk attempted to handpick his successor, an assistant coach named Tommy Raffo. Incoming athletic director Greg Byrne — a former assistant AD at Oregon State and the son of former Oregon AD Bill Byrne — disagreed.
Byrne hired Kentucky coach John Cohen to replace Polk. And you would have thought he sided with Judas.
“I just got slapped in the face, punched in the stomach,” Polk said, signing up for the overpopulated Society of Victims. “All my coaches have been slapped in the face, punched in the stomach by a young athletic director who has absolutely no clue what he’s doing.
“Now he’s got me on the warpath, and all I can do is hurt him. I’m going to do everything I can to make his life miserable.”
Wait a minute. Somebody did their job and made a decision that you disagree with, and now you vow to make their life miserable? Sounds perfectly reasonable, doesn’t it?
Welcome to Problem Solving 101: The Attila the Hun Method.
And that is where we get to the crux of the issue. That is where a seemingly minor spitting match way down in Mississippi becomes relevant up here in Washington.
Because in reading Polk’s comments, it is impossible not to wonder what in the world has happened to our national discussion, to our civility, to our ability to have a reasonable discourse.
Whether it’s presidential politics or college baseball or high school sports, we seem to have lost the ability to engage and the willingness to disagree. And it’s not just in Mississippi.
Why, a simple glance at the message boards on columbiantalk.com often unveils a loss of civility, a loss of our desire to partake in constructive rhetoric. Seemingly no coach is immune from the rantings or a disgruntled parent, regardless of the coach’s credentials.
One recent tirade against a high school coach ended with the demand that the school send the coach packing. Never mind that the coach has more league championships than fingers, including one last year. Never mind that the post was delivered anonymously, which is the height of cowardice.
Perhaps that is what is so disturbing about this trend. People feel empowered by anonymity, failing to realize that it only cloaks their argument in immaturity. Delivering anonymous criticism is a sign of weakness, not strength.
This trend is not exactly an epidemic. Most people remain reasonable in their ability to frame a disagreement or complain about a coach or criticize a politician. But there is enough vitriol out there to diminish us all.
I thought about all this as I read the comments from Polk. Oh, maybe it’s a stretch to go from a bitter baseball coach in Mississippi to an anonymous Internet user in Vancouver.
But I can’t help but think that there’s a connection. I can’t help but think that complaining and playing the role of victim has become a national pastime. I can’t help but think that too many of us have lost the ability to respectfully disagree.
And as our discussions devolve more and more into the realm of churlishness, I can’t help but think that we are that much poorer for it.
Greg Jayne is Sports editor of The Columbian. He can be reached at 360-735-4531, or by e-mail at greg.jayne@columbian.com. To read his blog, go to columbian.com/Sports/GregJayneBlog |