Californians have seen the light! It was a lantern waved by Washingtonians. Last Tuesday, 54 percent of California voters approved Proposition 14, which creates the same top two primary that 60 percent of voters in our state endorsed in 2004 and which has been OK’d by none other than the U.S. Supreme Court.
Starting next year in California, voters and not political parties will be in charge of primaries, and that’s the way it should be. Voters will consider all candidates, and the top two will advance — regardless of party affiliation — to the general election. Instead of serving as a intra-party nominating process (paid for by taxpayers), the top two primary is a winnowing process, the province of the public. Our state’s third top two primary is scheduled for Aug. 17, and the system has drawn widespread, bipartisan support.
Except for one group. Political party operatives hate it. Bashing the top two primary is one of the few things that Republican and Democratic party leaders have in common. This shared derision is explained in part by a recent Newsweek story analyzing the Californians’ decision: “The dance that all party candidates do — they play to the extremes of their base in the primary and then try to keep a straight face as they label themselves centrist for the general election — is no more. The backers of Prop. 14 figured that by eliminating primaries, candidates would have to be moderate from the beginning, making them more genuine and believable. Candidates will also have to cater to all voters, not just ones in their party.”
Those party officials in California even took to calling the top two primary the “jungle” primary because of its free-for-all nature. We prefer to call it the “people’s” primary.